GTA 6 hits 99 on Metacritic: what even the 10/10 reviews hold against it

Purple convertible seen from behind on a Florida seafront at sunset, palm trees and neon facades, with the text GTA 6 99 but flaws on Metacritic

Article by Kami

On the morning of Thursday, November 19, the GTA 6 Metacritic page for the PS5 version shows 99, the « Universal Acclaim » label and 150 critic reviews, all of them positive. The reviews landed on November 18, the day before launch, just as the embargo rumor we covered in October suggested.

GamesRadar (Scott McCrae) made it the headline: the GTA 6 Metacritic score makes it the highest-rated game of all time, level with the original Zelda: Ocarina of Time.

Headline of a GamesRadar article by Scott McCrae: the GTA 6 Metacritic score makes it the highest-rated game of all time, matching Zelda Ocarina of Time
GamesRadar, Scott McCrae, screenshot taken on November 19, 2026: GTA 6 level with Ocarina of Time at the top of Metacritic.

A 99 without a single mixed review does not mean zero complaints. Even the 10/10 reviews spend a few lines on what falls short, and those lines overlap. Here they are, with the names of the people who wrote them.

GTA 6 Metacritic: what a 99 across 150 reviews is worth

On the PS5 page, Metacritic counts 150 reviews, none mixed, none negative. The counter moves: Output Lag logged 153 at 11:44 pm on November 18, 147 of them positive, and showed OpenCritic at 99 across 89 reviews in its scoreboard but 98 in its quick-facts box. The user score still reads « tbd » (to be determined): it needs at least four ratings before it shows, and so far only the press has weighed in.

GTA 6 Metacritic page for Grand Theft Auto VI on PS5: Metascore 99, Universal Acclaim, 150 critic reviews, user score to be determined, released November 19, 2026
Metacritic, PS5 page read on the morning of November 19, 2026: 99 from 150 critic reviews.

This GTA 6 Metacritic average reads as a consensus on the essentials. Output Lag’s roundup describes a « generational » open world carried by Jason and Lucia, and the most reactive city Rockstar has built. The caveats fit on one line of that same page: the 30fps cap and a slower back half.

Output Lag roundup of GTA 6 reviews: Metacritic 99 from 153 reviews, OpenCritic 99, 147 of 147 reviews positive, and the line about the 30fps cap
Output Lag, Steven Mills, November 18, 2026: 99 on Metacritic, and « The 30fps cap and a slower back half are the caveats. »

30 frames per second: three reviewers, three reactions

The cap was known well before the GTA 6 Metacritic score landed: we covered it back in September. Output Lag points out that it applies to every console, PS5 Pro included, and that there is no performance mode (a setting that trades image quality for smoother motion).

Reviewers do not weigh it the same way. Luke Reilly, for IGN (10/10), waves the topic away: « I simply did not care in the slightest while I was actually playing », as long as the game looks great and runs smoothly and reliably on a standard PS5. Jimmy Donnellan, for Cultured Vultures (10/10), adds a nuance: « GTAVI targets 30fps, and for the majority of my playthrough, it felt like it did hit that target. » Then: « But there were moments, especially in high-octane chase sequences, where it seemed to dip way below it. » French site ActuGaming writes that the fluidity « was remarkably consistent throughout our adventure » (our translation).

Output Lag did the counting. Of the 18 reviews it read, 9 report drops below 30 frames per second « in dense city areas, big firefights, fast chases and late missions », and 8 fault the pacing of the story.

The two most cited caveats, out of 18 reviews read

Drops below 30 frames per second9 of 18
Story pacing criticised8 of 18

Source: Output Lag, roundup of November 18, 2026. Chart by our editorial team; one review can flag both.

The per-console breakdown, still according to Output Lag, describes a mostly stable game on PS5, while two reviews on Xbox Series X contradict each other. None of the reviews it read was played on an Xbox Series S.

ConsoleReviews covering itWhat they report
Base PS56 reviewsMostly stable at 30 frames per second, no crashes
PS5 Pro5 reviewsClose to locked, with PSSR upscaling and ray-traced shadows
Xbox Series X2 reviewsDisagreement: one smooth, one with drops below 30
Xbox Series S0 reviewsNo copy tested in the sample
Source: Output Lag, November 18, 2026. Table by our editorial team.

These drops are reviewers’ impressions, not frame-rate readouts. Output Lag’s page also gives a different split elsewhere, 4 reviewers happy against 5 on base-console performance, without explaining the gap with those 9 out of 18.

Missions, pacing, replayability: what the 10/10 reviews note at the bottom of the page

Another recurring caveat: mission structure and pacing. At Cultured Vultures, Jimmy Donnellan lists among his gripes the slow walking inherited from Red Dead Redemption 2: « That dreaded trundling is also unfortunately weaved into the structure of a lot of the missions », where you follow a character reeling off exposition, sometimes for minutes.

At ActuGaming (Quentin, November 18, noon), the main missions « unfortunately remain very scripted overall » (our translation). The review calls them « too directive » and says the story, « although gripping, does not always shine through its originality ». The score circle on the page shows 9.5 under a « readers’ score » label even though no reader has posted an opinion, so we do not quote an editorial score for this review.

ActuGaming's GTA 6 review page by Quentin, published November 18, 2026 at noon, with art of Jason and Lucia and a score circle reading 9.5
ActuGaming (French site), Quentin, November 18, 2026, noon: the review titled « Rockstar pushes the limits of the open world ».

🇬🇧 English translation of the ActuGaming page

ActuGaming (French site), review headline « Test GTA 6 : Rockstar repousse les limites du monde ouvert », by Quentin, published November 18, 2026 at 12:00

Headline

« GTA 6 review: Rockstar pushes the limits of the open world »

Opening lines

« That’s it, the video game industry can finally catch its breath. After more than a decade of waiting, Grand Theft Auto VI is finally in our hands. Few productions have sparked so much discussion, fed so many fantasies and built up so many expectations. Despite the leaks that somewhat spoiled the surprise, Rockstar managed to keep this buzz going by revealing very little in the end. We finished the adventure and traveled across Leonida, far and wide. The result is a production of boundless ambition that pushes the boundaries of immersion in an open world. But behind this show of force hides also a… »

On the page

  • Score circle: 9.5, labelled « readers’ score » (0 reviews posted yet).
  • 8 comments, « Share your opinion (0) ».

Translation by the editorial team, as close to the original as possible. The text cuts off where the screenshot ends.

IGN, which gives it a 10, flags a step back: it does not appear possible to replay completed missions from the mission list. Luke Reilly calls it an « unexpected step back » from GTA IV: The Ballad of Gay Tony and GTA V. The review writes « doesn’t appear », so the wording stays cautious.

What comes next is up to players. Their GTA 6 Metacritic score still reads « tbd », and it will show whether these caveats weigh as much for them as they do for the press.